ERBE 02 2 06
Is there a Greenium in the Corporate Green Bond Market?
PAULO ALVES a, EUCLIDES LOPES b and JOÃO PINTO a
a Universidade Católica Portuguesa, Católica Porto Business School and CEGE, Portugal; b Universidade Católica Portuguesa, Católica Porto Business School.
To cite this article:
Alves, Paulo, Lopes, Euclides & Pinto, João. 2023. Is there a Greenium in the Corporate Green Bond Market? European Review of Business Economics II(2): 119-134.
Published: June 2023
This paper examines the pricing of green bonds vis-à-vis standard corporate bonds. Using a cross-section of green bonds issued by corporates in the 2014–2021 period, we build a matched sample of quasi-identical conventional bonds and find a statistically insignificant green bond premium of -7.2 bps. These results remain identical when creating subsamples according to the currency of denomination (euro versus USD) and issuer types (financial versus nonfinancial firms), and when controlling for contractual, macroeconomic, and several fixed effects. Our findings imply that there is no pricing difference between bonds that mainly differ with respect to their green label, and investors are not willing to exchange financial returns for non-pecuniary environmental benefits.
Green bonds; corporate bonds; greenium; ESG.
Abah, A. L. (2016). Legal regulation of CSR: the case of social media and gender-based harassment. University of Baltimore Journal of Media Law & Ethics, 5, 38.
Adams, S. & Fries, J. & Simnett, R. (2011). The Journey Toward Integrated Reporting. Accountants Digest. 558. 1-41.
Almeyda, R. & Darmansya, A. (2019). The Influence of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Disclosure on Firm Financial Performance. IPTEK Journal of Proceedings Series, 0(5), 278.
Amao, O. (2013). Corporate social responsibility, human rights and the law: multinational corporations in developing countries. Abingdon: Routledge
Aupperle, K. E., Carroll, A. B. & Hatfield, J. D. (1985). An Empirical Examination of the Relationship Between Corporate Social Responsibility and Profitability. Academy of Management Journal, 28(2), 446–463.
Bachelet, M. J., Becchetti, L. & Manfredonia, S. (2019). The green bonds premium puzzle: The role of issuer characteristics and third-party verification. Sustainability (Switzerland), 11(4).
Baker, M., Bergstresser, D., Serafeim, G., and Wurgler, J. (2018). Financing the Response to Climate Change: The Pricing and Ownership of US Green Bonds, NBER Working Paper 25194.
Barrett, S. (1994). Self-Enforcing International Environmental Agreements. Oxford Economic Papers, 46, 878–894.
Buhmann, K. (2006). Corporate social responsibility: What role for law? Some aspects of law and CSR. Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society, 6(2), 188–202.
Buhmann, K. (2011). Integrating human rights in emerging regulation of corporate social responsibility: The EU case. International Journal of Law in Context, 7(2), 139–179.
Caramichael, J., and Rapp, A. (2022). The Green Corporate Bond Issuance Premium, International Finance Discussion Papers 1346. Washington: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
Cheng, S., Lin, K. Z. & Wong, W. (2016). Corporate social responsibility reporting and firm performance: evidence from China. Journal of Management and Governance, 20(3), 503–523.
Chiang, J. Growing the US Green Bond Market: Volume 1: The Barriers and Challenges; California State Treasurer: Sacramento, CA, USA, 2017.
Cicchiello, A., Cotugno, M., Monferrà, S., and Perdichizzi, S. (2022). Which are the factors influencing green bonds issuance? Evidence from the European bonds market, Finance Research Letters 50, 103190.
Commission on Environment, W. (n.d.). Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development: Our Common Future Towards Sustainable Development 2. Part II. Common Challenges Population and Human Resources 4.
Cortellini, G. & Panetta, I. C. (2021). Green Bond: A Systematic Literature Review for Future Research Agendas. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 14(12), 589.
De Spiegeleer, J. & Schoutens, W. (2019). Sustainable Capital Instruments and Their Role in Prudential Policy: Reverse Green Bonds. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Dietz, Simon, and Nicholas Stern. 2008. Why economic analysis supports strong action on climate change: A response to the Stern Review’s critics. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 2, no. 1:94–113.
Dorfleitner, G., Utz, S. & Zhang, R. (2021). The pricing of green bonds: external reviews and the shades of green. Review of Managerial Science.
Edmans, A. (2022). The End of ESG, Financial Management, forthcoming.
Edmans, A., and Kacperczyk, M. (2022). Sustainable Finance, Review of Finance, 1309-1313.
Ehlers, T., and Packer, F. (2017). Green bond finance and certification. BIS Quarterly Review, September.
Fama, E., & French, K. (2007) “Disagreement, Tastes, and Asset Prices.” Journal of Financial Economics. Vol. 83, No. 3.
Fatica, S. & Panzica, R. (n.d.). Sustainable investing in times of crisis: evidence from bond holdings and the COVID-19 pandemic.
Fatica, S., Panzica, R. & Rancan, M. (2021). The pricing of green bonds: Are financial institutions special? Journal of Financial Stability, 54, 100873.
Febi, Wulandari, Dorothea Schäfer, Andreas Stephan, and Chen Sun. 2018. The impact of liquidity risk on the yield spread of green bonds. Finance Research Letters 27: 53–59.
Flammer, C. (2012). Does Corporate Social Responsibility Lead to Superior Financial Performance? A Regression Discontinuity Approach. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Flammer, C. (2021). Corporate green bonds. Journal of Financial Economics, 142(2), 499–516.
Friedman, M. (1970) The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits. New York Times Magazine, 13 September 1970, 122-126.Gao, Y., and J. Schmittmann. (2022). Green Bond Pricing and greenwashing under Asymmetric Information, IMF Working Paper 246.
Gianfrate, G. & Peri, M. (2019). The green advantage: Exploring the convenience of issuing green bonds. Journal of Cleaner Production, 219, 127–135.
Goss, Allen & Roberts, Gordon S., 2011. “The impact of corporate social responsibility on the cost of bank loans,” Journal of Banking & Finance, Elsevier, vol. 35(7), pages 1794-1810, July.
Guild, J. (2020). The political and institutional constraints on green finance in Indonesia. Journal of Sustainable Finance and Investment, 10(2), 157–170.
Hachenberg, B. & Schiereck, D. (2018). Are green bonds priced differently from conventional bonds? Journal of Asset Management, 19(6), 371-383.
Hamilton, S., H. Jo and M. Statman. (1993). Doing Well While Doing Good? The Investment Performance of Socially Responsible Mutual Funds. Financial Analysts Journal 49, 62-66.
Höhne et al., (2012). Mapping of Green Finance Delivered by IDFC Members in 2011, Ecofys.
Horváthová, E. (2010). Does environmental performance affect financial performance? A meta-analysis. Ecological Economics, 70(1), 52–59.
Hutton, R. B., D’Antonio, L. & Johnsen, T. (2016). Socially Responsible Investing: Growing Issues and New Opportunities, Business and Society, 37, 281-306
Hyun, S., Park, D. & Tian, S. (2020). The price of going green: the role of greenness in green bond markets. Accounting & Finance, 60(1), 73–95.
ICMA. (2018). Green Bond Principles. Voluntary Process Guidelines for Issuing Green Bonds 8, International Capital Market Association.
Idemudia, U. & Kwakyewah, C. (2018). Analysis of the Canadian national corporate social responsibility strategy: Insights and implications. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 25(5), 928–938.
Johnston, A., Amaeshi, K., Adegbite, E., & & Osuji, O. K. (2019). Corporate Social Responsibility as Obligated Internalisation of Social Costs. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Jones, Ryan, Tom Baker, Katherine Huet, Laurence Murphy, and Nick Lewis. (2020). Treating ecological deficit with debt: The practical and political concerns with green bonds. Geoforum 114: 49–58
Kakabadse, A. & Morsing, M. (2006). Corporate Social Responsibility: Reconciling Aspiration with Application, 1–311.
Kanamura, T., Kanamura & Takashi. (2020). Are green bonds environmentally friendly and good performing assets? Energy Economics, 88(C).
Kapraun, J. & Scheins, C. (2019). (In)-Credibly Green: Which Bonds Trade at a Green Bond Premium? SSRN Electronic Journal.
Karpf, A. & Mandel, A. (2018). The changing value of the “green” label on the US municipal bond market. Nature Climate Change, 8(2), 161-165.
Labatt, S. & White, R.R. (2007). Carbon Finance: The Financial Implications of Climate Change.
Larcker, David F., and Edward M. Watts. 2020. Where’s the greenium? Journal of Accounting and Economics, Elsevier, vol. 69(2)
Lankoski, L. (2000). Determinants of Environmental Profit: An Analysis of the Firm-level Relationship Between Environmental Performance and Economic Performance.
Lin, B., and Su, T. (2022). Green bond vs conventional bond: Outline the rationale behind issuance choices in China. International Review of Financial Analysis 81, 102063.
Lindenberg, N. (2014). Definition of Green Finance.
Löffler, K., Petreski, A., and Stephan, A. (2021). Drivers of green bond issuance and new evidence on the “greenium”, Eurasian Economic Review 11, 1-24.
Malesky, E. & Taussig, M. (2017). The danger of not listening to firms: government responsiveness and the goal of regulatory compliance. The Academy of Management Journal, 60(5), 1741–1770.
Malesky, E. & Taussig, M. (2019). Participation, government legitimacy, and regulatory compliance in emerging economies: a firm-level field experiment in Vietnam. American Political Science Review, 113(2), 530–551
Mill, G. A. (2006). The Financial Performance of a Socially Responsible Investment Over Time and a Possible Link with Corporate Social Responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics 2006 63(2), 131–148.
Miroshnychenko, I., Barontini, R., & & Testa, F. (2017). Green practices and financial performance: A global outlook. Journal of Cleaner Production, 147, 340–351.
Nanayakkara, Madurika and Colombage, Sisira. (2018) Do Investors in Green Bond Market Pay a Risk Premium? Global Evidence (July 28, 2018). 31st Australasian Finance and Banking Conference.
Nieto, P. (2005). Why regulating: corporate social responsibility is a conceptual error and implies a dead weight for competitiveness. The European Enterprise Journal.
Nollet, J., Filis, G., & & Mitrokostas, E. (2016). Corporate social responsibility and financial performance: A non-linear and disaggregated approach. Undefined, 52, 400–407.
Okoye, A. (2016). Legal approaches and corporate social responsibility: towards a Llewellyn’s law-jobs approach. Abingdon: Routledge.
Orazayeva, A., & & Arslan, M. (2021). Development of corporate social responsibility framework for developing countries: the case of Kazakhstan. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Osuji, O. (2011). Fluidity of regulation-CSR nexus: the multinational corporate corruption example. Journal of Business Ethics, 103(1), 31–57.
Osuji, O. K. (2015). Corporate social responsibility, juridification and globalisation: ‘inventive interventionism’ for a ‘paradox’. International Journal of Law in Context, 11(3), 265–298.
Partridge, Candace, and Francesca Romana Medda. 2020. The evolution of pricing performance of green municipal bonds. Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment 10: 44–64
Pástor, L., Stambaugh, R., and Taylor, L. (2021). Sustainable investing in equilibrium, Journal of Financial Economics 142, 550-571.
Pedersen, L., Fitzgibbons, S., and Pomorski, L. (2021). Responsible investing: The ESG-efficient frontier, Journal of Financial Economics 142, 572-597.
Pollman, E. (2022). The Making and Meaning of ESG, European Corporate Governance Institute – Law Working Paper No. 659.
Porter, G., Bird, N., Kaur, N. and Peskett, L. (2008). “New Finance for Climate Change and the Environment”. Washington, DC: Heinrich Böll Foundation and WWF.
Preclaw, R., and A. Bakshi. 2015.The Cost of Being Green. USA: Barclays Research.
Raimo, N., Caragnano, A., Zito, M., Vitolla, F. & Mariani, M. (2021). Extending the benefits of ESG disclosure: The effect on the cost of debt financing. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 28(4), 1412–1421.
Renneboog, L., ter Horst, J. & Zhang, C. (2008). The price of ethics and stakeholder governance: The performance of socially responsible mutual funds. Journal of Corporate Finance, 14(3), 302–322.
Sachs, J., Woo, W., Yoshino, N., and Taghizadeh-Hesary, F. (2019). Importance of green finance for achieving sustainable development goals and energy security. In: Sachs, J., Woo, W., Yoshino, N., Taghizadeh-Hesary, F. (eds.), Handbook of Green Finance. Springer, Singapore.
Saunders, N. (2019). Climate change adaptation finance: are the most vulnerable nations prioritized?
Scoville-Simonds, M. (2016). The Governance of Climate Change Adaptation Finance—An Overview and Critique. Revue Internationale de Politique de Développement, 7(1)
Shalchian, H., Bouslah, K., & & M’Zali, B. (2015). A Multi-Dimensional Analysis of Corporate Social Responsibility: Different Signals in Different Industries. Journal of Financial Risk Management, 04(02), 92–109.
Situ, H., Tilt, C. A. & Seet, P. S. (2018). The influence of the government on corporate environmental reporting in China: an authoritarian capitalism perspective. Business & Society
Soppe, Aloy, Sustainable Finance as a Connection Between Corporate Social Responsibility and Social Responsible Investing (2009). Indian Management Research Journal, 1 (3), pp. 13-23.
Stern, Nicholas. 2008. “The Economics of Climate Change.” American Economic Review, 98 (2): 1-37. Tang, D. Y. & Zhang, Y. (2020). Do shareholders benefit from green bonds? Journal of Corporate Finance, 61.
Thirarungrueang, K. (2013). Rethinking CSR in Australia: time for binding regulation? International Journal of Law and Management, 55(3), 173–200.
Ullmann, A.E. (1985) Data in Search of a Theory: A Critical Examination of the Relationship’s among Social Performance, Social Disclosure and Economic Performance of US Firms. Academy of Management Review, 10, 540-557.
Vance, S. (1975). Are Socially Responsible Corporations Good Investment Risks? Managerial Review, 64, 18-24.
Velte, P. (2017). Does ESG performance have an impact on financial performance? Evidence from Germany. Journal of Global Responsibility, 8(2), 169–178.
Verbeeten, F. H. M., Gamerschlag, R. & Möller, K. (2016). Are CSR disclosures relevant for investors? Empirical evidence from Germany. Management Decision, 54(6), 1359–1382.
Wagner, M.; van Phu, N.; Wehrmeyer, W. The relationship between the environmental and economic performance of ﬁrms: An empirical analysis of the European paper industry. Corp. Soc. Responsib. Environ. Manag. 2002,9, 133–146.
Wang, X., & Wang, S. (2020). The Impact of Green Finance on Inclusive Economic Growth—Empirical Analysis Based on Spatial Panel. Open Journal of Business and Management, 8(05), 2093.
Wang, Y., and Zhi, Q. (2016). The Role of Green Finance in Environmental Protection: Two Aspects of Market Mechanism and Policies, Energy Procedia 104, 311-316.
Xiao, Y., Faff, R., Gharghori, P. & Lee, D. (2013). An Empirical Study of the World Price of Sustainability. Journal of Business Ethics, 114(2), 297–310.
Yu, F. (2005). Accounting transparency and the term structure of credit spread, Journal of Financial Economics 75, 53-84.
Zadek, S., Flynn, C. (2013). South-Originating Green Finance: Exploring the Potential, The Geneva International Finance Dialogues, UNEP FI, SDC, and iisd.
Zerbib, O. D. (2019). The effect of pro-environmental preferences on bond prices: Evidence from green bonds. Journal of Banking & Finance, 98, 39-60.